Knowledge / Vietnam

Historical figures

What Do Old Histories Say About Triệu Quang Phục and Dạ Trạch Marsh?

Culture and belief A record of custom.

What Do Old Histories Say About Triệu Quang Phục and Dạ Trạch Marsh?

TL;DR: Triệu Quang Phục was the son of the Grand Tutor Triệu Túc from Chu Diên district. He followed Lý Nam Đế in his campaigns and was appointed Left General, and after Lý Nam Đế died he proclaimed himself king, that is Triệu Việt Vương. He withdrew to the Dạ Trạch marsh, where the grass and trees grew thick, hiding all fires and smoke by day and using dugout canoes to raid Trần Bá Tiên's camp by night, so his contemporaries called him Dạ Trạch Vương. The old histories differ on how complete this story is, for the Đại Việt sử ký toàn thư tells us that most of the material on Triệu Việt Vương and Đào Lang Vương had to be gathered from unofficial histories and other books to fill the gap.

Who was Triệu Quang Phục and where is Dạ Trạch marsh?

Triệu Quang Phục was the son of the Grand Tutor Triệu Túc, a man of Chu Diên district, who followed his father in aiding Lý Nam Đế, earned merit, and was made Left General[1]. Dạ Trạch marsh lay in Chu Diên territory, a winding swampy tract with dense vegetation and tangled banks, containing within it a raised patch of ground where people could live. This was the key base during his resistance against the Liang.

Historical background in the time of Lý Nam Đế

In 544, Lý Bí ascended the throne, named the state Vạn Xuân, established his capital at Long Biên, and changed the era name to Thiên Đức. Liang forces crossed in, Trần Bá Tiên was sent as the general on campaign, the two sides fought several battles, and the Lý forces lost ground and had to withdraw into Khuất Nao cave. Đại Việt sử ký toàn thư records that Lý Nam Đế entrusted Triệu Quang Phục with defending the country and training troops to fight Bá Tiên.

Why did Triệu Quang Phục withdraw into Dạ Trạch marsh?

After Lý Nam Đế retreated to Khuất Nao cave, Triệu Quang Phục held out against Trần Bá Tiên, but Bá Tiên's troops were very strong, and judging his strength insufficient he withdrew to hold Dạ Trạch. This was a decision based on naturally difficult terrain, not a simple retreat.

The terrain of Dạ Trạch marsh as recorded in old histories

The book Đại Việt sử ký toàn thư states that Dạ Trạch marsh belonged to Chu Diên territory, wound on for an unknown number of miles, had dense vegetation and thickly packed banks, and inside had ground where houses could be built. On all four sides was deep sinking mud, hard for people and horses to cross; only small dugout canoes poled through the grass and water could enter, and strangers to the paths would lose their way without knowing direction, and if they happened to fall into the water they would be bitten to death or wounded by snakes.

How Triệu Quang Phục fought at Dạ Trạch

Triệu Quang Phục knew every path, and brought more than twenty thousand men to camp on the ground in the middle of the marsh. By day he had all smoke, fire, and traces of people extinguished; by night he used dugout canoes to carry troops out to attack Bá Tiên's camps, killing and capturing very many. This way of fighting meant the Liang troops could never win, and contemporaries called him Dạ Trạch Vương[1].

When did Triệu Quang Phục proclaim himself king?

In the third month, spring of the year Mậu Thìn (548), on the day Tân Hợi, Lý Nam Đế, having long lain ill in Khuất Nao cave with a water-borne ailment, died. Đại Việt sử ký toàn thư records that he took the title of king once Nam Đế had died and counts Mậu Thìn as his first year[1]; Việt Nam sử lược says it was the following year (549) that he received the news at Dạ Trạch and proclaimed himself Việt Vương[2].

The turning point thanks to the Hầu Cảnh rebellion in Liang

At that time Việt Vương's troops had nearly run out of provisions, and despite constant fighting could not break the Liang forces. Then the Hầu Cảnh rebellion broke out in Liang, and the Liang emperor had to recall Trần Bá Tiên, leaving only a subordinate general named Dương Sàn behind to resist. Triệu Quang Phục seized that opportunity to lead his troops out and rout the Liang forces, then returned to retake Long Biên citadel[2]. Đại Việt sử ký toàn thư places this in the year Canh Ngọ (550) and records that Dương Sàn was defeated and killed[1].

His military territory and the boundary with Lý Phật Tử

After making peace with Lý Phật Tử, Triệu Việt Vương based himself at Long Biên and Lý Phật Tử at Ô Diên, with the Quân Thần sandbank as the boundary[2]. Đại Việt sử ký toàn thư records that Phật Tử asked for Triệu Việt Vương's daughter Cảo Nương as a wife for his son Nhã Lang; the two houses became in-laws and Nhã Lang came to live with his wife's family[1]. Việt Nam sử lược adds that Phật Tử still harbored designs of annexation, outwardly friendly while inwardly preparing to attack and take Long Biên[2].

Do old histories record Triệu Việt Vương fully?

Đại Việt sử ký toàn thư states clearly: old histories did not record the story of Triệu Việt Vương together with Đào Lang Vương, and one had to gather from unofficial histories and other books to record the royal titles of these two kings and fill the gap. This is an important admission by the historian about the state of the source material.

How do the sources differ?

SourceMain content on Triệu Quang Phục and Dạ TrạchNature of the material
Đại Việt sử ký toàn thư (Ngô Sĩ Liên, 1479, Mạc Bảo Thần translation 1945)Records the withdrawal to hold Dạ Trạch, the night fighting, the proclamation as king, and the division of territory with Lý Phật TửOfficial history, but itself admits the Triệu Việt Vương portion had to be filled from unofficial histories
Việt Nam sử lược (Trần Trọng Kim, 1920)Summarizes events from the withdrawal to Dạ Trạch through the proclamation as Việt Vương and the division of territory with Lý Phật Tử[2]Popular history, inheriting old histories, presented concisely
Đại Nam quốc sử diễn ca (Lê Ngô Cát and collaborators, 1870)Versified account of Triệu Quang Phục defeating the Liang, holding Dạ Trạch marsh, and the split with Lý Phật TửVersified narrative with literary elements, not a substitute for official history

Why does the name Dạ Trạch Vương matter?

The name Dạ Trạch Vương is tied to a specific tactic, and it shows how old histories recognized a leader's prestige through the territory he controlled. Contemporaries called him this, rather than it being a self-proclaimed title[1].

From Dạ Trạch Vương to Triệu Việt Vương

After Lý Nam Đế died, Triệu Quang Phục proclaimed himself Việt Vương, established his capital at Long Biên, later moved to Vũ Ninh, and reigned for twenty-three years. Old histories comment that he held a strategic position and devised unusual schemes to defeat a great enemy, but regrettably loved his daughter too much and brought about the disaster of the son-in-law.

The place names Chu Diên and Long Biên today

The place names Chu Diên, Long Biên, and Dạ Trạch in old histories belong to the administrative boundaries of the period of Northern domination, different from current administrative units. When comparing with modern maps, one should note these are ancient administrative names, not identical to today's commune or ward names.

Does the story of Triệu Việt Vương contain legendary elements?

Yes, and that element sits inside the official history itself. Đại Việt sử ký toàn thư records that in the year Kỷ Tỵ (549) Triệu Quang Phục, in the marsh, burned incense and prayed, obtained a helmet with a dragon claw, and from then on was unbeatable wherever he fought; it adds that "tradition has it" the spirit of the marsh was Chử Đồng Tử, who rode a golden dragon and handed him the claw[1]. Đại Nam quốc sử diễn ca retells this in verse: the golden dragon gives a claw to fasten on the rim of his helmet, and with the dragon claw on his head no army dared face him[3]. This is a legendary detail, not a historical record in the modern sense.

How to distinguish the historical layer from the legendary layer

The Lê dynasty historians, when writing the Triệu Việt Vương section, stated clearly that it had to be gathered from unofficial histories, meaning they themselves were aware of the boundary between official and unofficial history. The legend of the golden dragon giving a claw, which Đại Việt sử ký toàn thư records with the words "tradition has it" and Đại Nam quốc sử diễn ca retells, reflects folk belief in sacred assistance for a resistance leader.

Points on which sources still disagree

Because official history states clearly that the Triệu Việt Vương story had to be filled from unofficial histories, the specific details about the time of his proclamation as king, the number of years he reigned, and his relationship with Lý Phật Tử have no surviving contemporary record for independent verification. Figures such as twenty-three years of reign or more than twenty thousand men stationed at Dạ Trạch are historical records passed down, not contemporary census data.

The location of Dạ Trạch marsh today

The main text of Đại Việt sử ký toàn thư only records that Dạ Trạch marsh was in Chu Diên territory. A note in the 1945 translation places Dạ Trạch in Đông An district, Khoái Châu prefecture[1], and Việt Nam sử lược likewise glosses it as Khoái Châu prefecture, Hưng Yên province[2], while the same book glosses Chu Diên as Vĩnh Tường in the former Vĩnh Yên province. These are administrative names of the Nguyễn period and the early twentieth century, so the exact location of the marsh should not be asserted with certainty.

Nhật Nguyệt's suggestion for reading the story of Triệu Quang Phục

Gợi ý của Nhật Nguyệt: When reading the story of Triệu Quang Phục and Dạ Trạch marsh, one should separate it into three layers. The first layer is the events recorded by official history, such as the withdrawal to Dạ Trạch, the night fighting, and the proclamation as king. The second layer is the details historians had to fill from unofficial histories, which should be read with a certain caution. The third layer is legendary details such as the golden dragon giving a claw, which belong more to folk culture than to historical material. Reading in these three layers helps avoid both extremes: either rejecting everything because of legendary elements, or accepting every detail as a proven event.

Was this useful to you?

Share:

Frequently asked questions

Who was Triệu Quang Phục and why was he called Dạ Trạch Vương?

Triệu Quang Phục was the son of the Grand Tutor Triệu Túc from Chu Diên district. He followed his father in aiding Lý Nam Đế and was appointed Left General. When the Liang army under Trần Bá Tiên advanced, he withdrew to hold the Dạ Trạch marsh, hiding all fires and smoke by day and using dugout canoes to raid the enemy camp by night, so his contemporaries called him Dạ Trạch Vương.

How do the old histories describe the Dạ Trạch marsh?

The Đại Việt sử ký toàn thư records that the Dạ Trạch marsh lay in Chu Diên district, winding for an unknown number of leagues, with dense trees and tangled brush along its banks, and habitable ground within. Mud on all four sides made it hard going for men and horses; only dugout canoes poled over the grass and water could reach it, and those unfamiliar with the paths easily lost their way.

Do the old histories record the story of Triệu Việt Vương in full?

Not entirely. The Đại Việt sử ký toàn thư states plainly that the old histories did not record the story of Triệu Việt Vương together with Đào Lang Vương, so the historians had to gather from unofficial histories and other books to fill the gap. Some details about when he proclaimed himself king and his relationship with Lý Phật Tử should therefore be read with caution.

Related articles

Related lookup tools

References

  1. ↑ abcdefghNgô Sĩ Liên và Mạc Bảo Thần (dịch) (1945). Đại Việt sử ký toàn thư, bản dịch Mạc Bảo Thần (Nhượng Tống), Tân Việt 1945, Tập I phần Tiền Lý Nam Đế; Tập II, Cuốn thứ tư, Đời Triệu Việt VươngXét ra, sử cũ không chép truyện Triệu-Việt-Vương cùng Đào-Lang-Vương. Nay nhặt trong Dã sử cùng sách khác, mới chép vị hiệu Triệu-Việt-Vương cùng Đào-Lang-Vương để bù vào.
  2. ↑ abcdefTrần Trọng Kim (1920). Việt Nam sử lược, Quyển I, phần thuộc nhà Lương, mục Triệu Việt VươngDạ-trạch là chỗ đồng lầy, chung quanh cỏ mọc như rừng, ở giữa có bãi cát làm nhà ở được.
  3. ↑Lê Ngô Cát và cộng sự (1870). Đại Nam quốc sử diễn ca, Mục Triệu Quang Phục phá LươngBấy giờ Triệu mới thừa ky, Cứ đầm Dạ Trạch, liệu bề tấn công.
#TriệuQuangPhục#TriệuViệtVương#DạTrạchMarsh#DạTrạchVương#LýNamĐế#EarlyLýDynasty#VietnameseHistory#ĐạiViệtSửKýToànThư