
TL;DR: In Kỳ Môn Độn Giáp, the dụng thần is the component on the board assigned to stand for the querent, the people involved or the matter, and choosing it correctly decides the whole reading. Kỳ Môn Độn Giáp nguyên linh kinh and Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu assign different dụng thần for the same matter, so you must state which book you follow before judging sinh khắc. This is a convention of the school, not scientifically verified, and must not replace real decisions on litigation, loans or marriage.
Choosing the yòng shén in Qí Mén Dùn Jiǎ: for each question, which stem, gate, star or deity do you take?
What is the yòng shén in Qí Mén Dùn Jiǎ?
The yòng shén is the element on the Qí Mén board assigned to represent the person asking, the people involved, or the matter being asked about. A single Qí Mén reading has many layers: the stems (heavenly stems and earthly stems), the eight gates, the nine stars, the eight deities, and the palace positions. Without a yòng shén you do not know which pair to compare for generating and overcoming, and the whole reading loses its foothold.
Three arts share the words "yòng shén" but use them for three different jobs. In Bát Tự (BaZi), the yòng shén is the element that needs supplementing in the chart, chosen on the basis of the stems and branches of the four pillars. In Lục Hào (six-line divination), the yòng shén is the line representing the matter, chosen by type of matter and by the six relations. In Qí Mén, the yòng shén is a specific cell on the board: a stem, a gate, a star or a deity, depending on the question. The three arts cannot borrow each other's yòng shén as substitutes.
Why does choosing the wrong yòng shén make the whole reading wrong?
Choose the wrong yòng shén and every later comparison of generating and overcoming, of vigour and decline, of void, is calculated on an unrelated object. For example, if you ask about borrowing money and mistakenly take Thiên Ất as the creditor instead of Trực Phù, the answer reverses the relationship: the borrower gets read as the lender.
A wrong yòng shén also drags the whole frame of reference wrong with it. Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu uses Trực Phù as the owner of the money, Thiên Ất as the borrower, and the Sinh gate as the wealth deity in lending and borrowing. Swap the roles and the entire chain of generating and overcoming among the three palaces is inverted, and a conclusion of "yes" becomes "no". So the first step in any reading is to pin down the question exactly, and only then to look up the yòng shén table of the book you are following.
In marriage, whom do Ất and Canh stand for, and what is Lục Hợp?
The Kỳ Môn Độn Giáp nguyên linh kinh records: "凡占婚姻,以乙为女,以庚为夫" (for divining marriage, take Ất as the woman, Canh as the man), meaning Ất is taken as the woman's side and Canh as the man's side. The book instructs you to examine the two palaces of Ất and Canh: if the two palaces generate and combine, the matter succeeds; if they clash or overcome each other, it does not succeed.
As for the matchmaker, the nguyên linh kinh takes "顶盘六合为媒人" (the Lục Hợp on the top plate as the matchmaker), that is, Lục Hợp at the heavenly plate level is the matchmaker. If Lục Hợp generates the palace of Ất, the matchmaking leans toward the bride's family; if it generates the palace of Canh, it leans toward the groom's family. Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu follows the same assignment: Ất is the bride's family, Canh is the groom's family, and Lục Hợp on the heavenly plate is the match.
The books also examine further signs in the palaces. The nguyên linh kinh holds that if Ất carries the "kích hình" pattern, the woman's side is read as fierce-tempered, while if Ất generates and combines, the woman's side is gentle; if Canh carries an inauspicious deity, the man's side is read as hot-tempered, while if it carries generating and combining, he is mild. These are the book's judgements, not descriptions of real people.
Some cases the books assign differently. Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu, in the section "divining the taking of a concubine", takes Ất as the principal wife, Đinh as the concubine, and Canh as the husband. The nguyên linh kinh again has a method for "divining uxorilocal marriage" (the bride's family receiving the groom), where one takes the palace of Canh on the heavenly plate generating the palace of Ất on the earthly plate, that is, the reverse direction from ordinary marriage.
The assignment of Ất, Canh and Lục Hợp is a convention of the book, has not been scientifically verified, and should not be used to decide a real marriage.
In borrowing and lending money, whom do Trực Phù, Thiên Ất and the Sinh gate stand for?
Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu, in the section "divining lending" (cho vay), records: "以直符为财主,天乙为取财之人,生门为财神" (take Trực Phù as the owner of the money, Thiên Ất as the person receiving the money, the Sinh gate as the wealth deity), meaning Trực Phù is the owner of the money, Thiên Ất is the recipient of the money, and the Sinh gate is the wealth deity. The book instructs you to compare generating and overcoming, and vigour and decline, among the three palaces in order to judge.
The same book, in the section "divining borrowing" (vay mượn), assigns differently: Trực Phù is the owner of the money, Thiên Ất is the borrower, and then one examines generating and overcoming between the two palaces. The section "divining a request for a loan" (asking whether a loan can be obtained) takes Trực Phù as the owner of the money, the day stem as the borrower, and examines both the year destiny and the day stem. So for the single matter of borrowing, the book has given at least two different assignments for the borrower.
The nguyên linh kinh has a method for "divining the redeeming of pawned property" that assigns quite differently: Trực Phù is the active side, Thiên Ất is the passive side, Trực Sử is the intermediary. The book instructs that if we are redeeming from someone, we are Trực Phù and the other party is Thiên Ất; if someone is redeeming from us, it is reversed. If Trực Sử generates both sides, the matter succeeds; if it overcomes both sides, it does not succeed.
In litigation, whom do the Khai gate, Trực Phù, Thiên Ất and the Kinh gate stand for?
Kỳ Môn Độn Giáp nguyên linh kinh, in the section "divining lawsuits", records: "须以开门为问官,值符为原告,天乙为被告,惊门为讼神" (one must take the Khai gate as the examining official, Trực Phù as the plaintiff, Thiên Ất as the defendant, the Kinh gate as the litigation deity), meaning the Khai gate is the official hearing the matter, Trực Phù is the plaintiff, Thiên Ất is the defendant, and the Kinh gate is the deity of litigation. The book instructs you to examine generating and overcoming among the palaces: if both the Khai gate and the Kinh gate overcome the palace of Thiên Ất, the defendant loses; if both overcome the palace of Trực Phù, the plaintiff loses; if one overcomes the plaintiff and the other overcomes the defendant, both sides lose.
Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu follows the same assignment but adds a role for the Kinh gate: "以直符为原告,以天乙为被告,以开门为问官,惊门为讼师" (take Trực Phù as the plaintiff, Thiên Ất as the defendant, the Khai gate as the examining official, the Kinh gate as the advocate), that is, the Kinh gate is the advocate. The book also examines Trực Sử and Lục Hợp for matters involving documents and witnesses.
The nguyên linh kinh also has a section "divining the bringing of a suit" that assigns differently: it takes Đinh as the petition, Chu Tước as the advocate, and examines Đinh and Chu Tước in the same palace. The section "divining official matters: postponement or urgency" again takes Trực Phù as the senior official, Lục Đinh as the official document, and Trực Sử as the messenger. So for the single matter of litigation, sections within the same book use different sets of yòng shén depending on the aspect being asked about.
When something is lost, what do Giáp Tý Mậu and Huyền Vũ stand for?
The nguyên linh kinh, in the section "divining lost objects", records: "以甲子戊为财物" (take Giáp Tý Mậu as the property), that is, Giáp Tý Mậu is taken as the goods. The book instructs: if Huyền Vũ is seen, it was stolen by someone; if Huyền Vũ is not seen, you lost it yourself. If the palace of Huyền Vũ overcomes the palace of Thanh Long, or the palace of Thanh Long generates the palace of Huyền Vũ, then it was certainly stolen.
The book also instructs you to examine void: if Giáp Tý Mậu falls in a void palace, then whether it was lost by yourself or stolen, it is hard to recover. To know where it was lost, look at the palace of Giáp Tý Mậu: in the four inner palaces, the object is still in the house; in the four outer palaces, it was lost far away. The book also uses the images of the eight trigrams to guess at the object: the Cấn palace is a mountain, the youngest son, the northeast direction; the Chấn palace is wood, the eldest son, due east.
Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu has a different assignment for lost objects: it takes the hour stem as the person who lost it, the eight gates as the lost object, and then examines vigour and decline and the eight deities. The section "divining thieves" takes Huyền Vũ and Thiên Bồng as the thief, the Thương gate as the catcher, and the hour stem as the owner of the object. So for the single matter of a lost object, the nguyên linh kinh uses Giáp Tý Mậu and Huyền Vũ, while pháp khiếu uses the hour stem and the eight gates.
Planning what to do and what to avoid according to each of the Cửu Tinh
Kỳ Môn Độn Giáp thống tông devotes a section to each of the Cửu Tinh (nine stars), recording what should and should not be done when that star is in charge. This is an assignment of yòng shén by star, different from the assignment by stem or by gate in the sections above.
For example, the star Thiên Phụ: "辅星宜修道设教、诛凶伐暴、入官见贵、嫁娶、移徙、商贾、营建、应举、谋望" (the Phụ star is suitable for cultivating the Way and establishing teachings, punishing the wicked and striking down the violent, entering officialdom and seeing nobles, marriage, moving house, trade, construction, sitting examinations, and seeking great aims), meaning Thiên Phụ suits cultivating the Way, founding teachings, removing the wicked, entering the gates of office, marriage, moving house, trade, construction, examinations, and pursuing great matters.
For example, the star Thiên Bồng: "蓬星宜安抚边境,修筑城池,不宜入官见贵、嫁娶、移徙、商贾、营建" (the Bồng star is suitable for pacifying the borders, building and repairing city walls, and unsuitable for entering officialdom and seeing nobles, marriage, moving house, trade, and construction), meaning Thiên Bồng suits keeping the borders quiet and building walls, and does not suit entering the gates of office, marriage, moving house, trade, or construction.
The book adds a further condition: "右九星有气而合奇门,吉者益吉,凶者减凶。若无气而不合奇门,凶者益凶,吉者不吉" (if the nine stars have qi and accord with the qí mén, the auspicious become more auspicious and the inauspicious lessen their harm; if they lack qi and do not accord with the qí mén, the inauspicious become more inauspicious and the auspicious turn unauspicious), meaning if a star has qi and accords with the qí mén, good becomes better and bad becomes less bad; if a star lacks qi and does not accord with the qí mén, bad becomes worse and good turns not good.
Where the books assign differently for the same matter
The table below gathers the yòng shén assignments that the books cited in this article give for each matter. The column "other role" records the other party, the intermediary, or the secondary element that the book assigns alongside.
| Matter asked | Yòng shén according to the book | Other role | Book |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marriage | Ất is the woman's side, Canh is the man's side | Lục Hợp (heavenly plate) is the matchmaker | Kỳ Môn Độn Giáp nguyên linh kinh; Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu |
| Taking a concubine | Ất is the principal wife, Đinh is the concubine, Canh is the husband | Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu | |
| Uxorilocal marriage (bride's family receives the groom) | Canh (heavenly plate) generates Ất (earthly plate) | Kỳ Môn Độn Giáp nguyên linh kinh | |
| Lending | Trực Phù is the owner of the money, Thiên Ất is the recipient of the money, the Sinh gate is the wealth deity | Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu | |
| Borrowing | Trực Phù is the owner of the money, Thiên Ất is the borrower | Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu | |
| Asking for a loan | Trực Phù is the owner of the money, the day stem is the borrower | Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu | |
| Redeeming pawned property | Trực Phù is the active side, Thiên Ất is the passive side | Trực Sử is the intermediary | Kỳ Môn Độn Giáp nguyên linh kinh |
| Litigation | The Khai gate is the examining official, Trực Phù is the plaintiff, Thiên Ất is the defendant, the Kinh gate is the litigation deity | Kỳ Môn Độn Giáp nguyên linh kinh | |
| Litigation (pháp khiếu) | Trực Phù is the plaintiff, Thiên Ất is the defendant, the Khai gate is the examining official, the Kinh gate is the advocate | Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu | |
| Bringing a suit, drafting a petition | Đinh is the petition, Chu Tước is the advocate | Kỳ Môn Độn Giáp nguyên linh kinh | |
| Official matters, postponement | Trực Phù is the senior official, Lục Đinh is the official document | Trực Sử is the messenger | Kỳ Môn Độn Giáp nguyên linh kinh |
| Lost object | Giáp Tý Mậu is the property, Huyền Vũ is the one who took it | Kỳ Môn Độn Giáp nguyên linh kinh | |
| Lost object (pháp khiếu) | The hour stem is the person who lost it, the eight gates are the lost object | Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu | |
| Theft | Huyền Vũ and Thiên Bồng are the thief, the Thương gate is the catcher | The hour stem is the owner of the object | Kỳ Môn pháp khiếu |
| What to do according to the star | The star in charge (for example Thiên Phụ, Thiên Bồng) | Kỳ Môn Độn Giáp thống tông |
The table shows that for the same matter the books can assign different yòng shén, and even within a single book different sections assign differently depending on the aspect being asked about. On this point the books are not consistent, and no research has yet verified which assignment is more correct. So when reading a Qí Mén board, the first thing is to state clearly which book you are following, and only then to judge. Mixing one book's yòng shén with another book's method of judgement will give results that cannot be verified.
Frequently asked questions
In Qí Mén, how do the yòng shén and the configuration differ?
The yòng shén is the element assigned to represent the person or matter, while the configuration is the combination of stems, gates, stars and deities on the board used to judge auspiciousness and inauspiciousness. The yòng shén is chosen first, the configuration examined afterwards; choose the wrong yòng shén and even a correct configuration cannot save the reading.
Can I use the yòng shén of Bát Tự or Lục Hào in place of Qí Mén's?
No. Bát Tự chooses the yòng shén as the element that needs supplementing in the chart, Lục Hào chooses the yòng shén as the line representing the matter according to the six relations, while Qí Mén chooses the yòng shén as a specific cell on the board. The three arts use the same words but for three different jobs, and cannot substitute for one another.
If two books assign different yòng shén for the same matter, which book should I follow?
Follow the book that the reader has chosen as the frame of reference for that reading, and state clearly which book you are following. Do not mix one book's yòng shén with another book's method of judgement, because the result will be neither verifiable nor reproducible.
