
TL;DR: Vietnamese-style Tử Vi and Vương Đình Chi's Trung Châu phái differ mainly in method: Vietnamese books use many auxiliary stars, rank stars by brightness level, and follow verse-based judgments for each pattern; the Trung Châu school does not rank stars, builds its framework from twelve basic boards and sixty star systems, and calls some familiar Vietnamese-book patterns false patterns (ngụy cách). These are differences in each school's conventions, with no scientific verification of accuracy.
How does the Vietnamese style of Tử Vi (Vietnamese astrology) differ from Wang Tingzhi's Zhongzhou school, and in which rules? A comparison of method between Tân Biên, cụ Thiên Lương, Việt Viêm Tử and the Trung Châu school
Where do the Vietnamese style of Tử Vi and the Trung Châu school differ?
The root difference lies in how star placement and interpretation are organised, not in which book is right and which is wrong. Twentieth-century Vietnamese Tử Vi books, most notably Tử Vi đẩu số tân biên by Vân Đằng Thái Thứ Lang, usually list and place a great many auxiliary stars, then grade each star as miếu, vượng, đắc or hãm in order to judge character and fortune through individual verse lines. Wang Tingzhi's Zhongzhou school (real name Tan Xiyong) takes another direction: it does not grade stars, does not rely on ready-made lookup tables, but builds a framework from twelve basic boards and sixty star systems, then interprets through the interaction between those systems[1].
One thing should be said at once: these are two different conventional traditions within the same discipline, and no study has verified that either school predicts more accurately. This article compares methods, not value.
How do the number of stars and the ranking of stars differ?
Vietnamese books use many auxiliary stars and grade stars by brightness; the Trung Châu school does not grade stars and holds that grading harms interpretation.
Tử Vi đẩu số tân biên by Vân Đằng Thái Thứ Lang presents each group of stars with its own placement rules, and each principal star has an outline section saying how that star, whether miếu or hãm, affects character, physique and fortune. For Cự Môn, for instance, the book writes: "Cự miếu, vượng hay đắc địa là người thông minh, nhân hậu, vui vẻ, có mưu cơ... được hưởng giàu sang và sống lâu" (Cự Môn in miếu, vượng or đắc địa is an intelligent, kind, cheerful person, resourceful... enjoying wealth, honour and long life), while in hãm it is read in another direction. That is the method of taking a star's brightness as the anchor for every judgement.
Wang Tingzhi in Trung Châu phái Tử Vi đẩu số: sơ cấp giảng nghĩa recounts that the Liu Binzhao tradition, when transmitting star placement, did not grade stars, and points out the harm of grading: sometimes a whole star system changes character merely because it meets a star ranked in the lowest grade, and the student, seeing "low grade", takes it lightly and so predicts wrongly[2]. He also says his school's star placement differs from both the popular table and Liu Binzhao's version, especially in the four transformations of the stems Mậu, Canh and Nhâm[2].
Learning combinations: why does the Trung Châu school build a framework of twelve boards and sixty star systems?
The Trung Châu school takes twelve basic boards and sixty star systems as its study framework, while Vietnamese books follow verse judgements for each specific configuration.
Wang Tingzhi writes in the upper volume of Trung Châu phái Tử Vi đẩu số: thâm tạo giảng nghĩa that Tử Vi has only twelve basic boards, that the fourteen principal stars combine into thirty-eight groups, distributed across six structures to make sixty star systems; to interpret, one must grasp the nature of each star system and the "intercourse" between systems. He criticises the method of looking only at the three directions and four cardinal stars of a single palace as superficial, because the same star in the same palace reacts differently when placed on people with different underlying destinies.
Vietnamese books take another path: each configuration and each group of stars is tied to a Sino-Vietnamese verse line, and the student memorises the verse then checks it against the chart. Việt Viêm Tử's Tử Vi áo bí biện chứng học (under the pen name Hà Lạc Dã Phu) is a clear example: the book discusses principal and auxiliary stars palace by palace, with Sino-Vietnamese verse lines such as "Nhật Nguyệt tịnh minh: Nhật ở Tỵ, Nguyệt ở Dậu, Mệnh an Sửu" (Sun and Moon both bright: the Sun in Tỵ, the Moon in Dậu, the Mệnh palace placed in Sửu). This way of learning gives quick results for those familiar with the verses, but offers little guidance on handling charts that fall into situations the verses do not mention.
Configurations: why does Wang Tingzhi call Tả Hữu thủ viên and Thiên Ất củng mệnh false configurations?
Wang Tingzhi calls certain familiar configurations "ngụy cách" (false configurations) on grounds of star placement and star position, while Vietnamese books still record those configurations as good ones.
In Vương Đình Chi đàm đẩu số, in the section on configurations, he classes "Tả Hữu đồng cung" (Tả Phù and Hữu Bật in the same palace) as a false configuration. His stated reason: Tả Phù and Hữu Bật are only supporting stars, like two side dishes on a tray, which cannot replace the main dish; the position of these two stars depends only on the birth month, so if that configuration held, anyone born in the fourth or tenth lunar month would have a noble configuration, which is absurd. He also calls "Thiên Ất củng mệnh" (Khôi Việt hội mệnh) a false configuration, because Khôi and Việt are placed by the year stem, so very many people have that configuration, and the two stars are not principal stars and lack the strength to "củng" into a great configuration.
Vietnamese books still record these configurations in their configuration sections, with verse lines praising them. That is not Vietnamese books being "wrong" in any absolute sense, but two schools setting different standards for whether a combination of stars deserves to be called a configuration. holds that a configuration must be led by a principal star and must be distinctive; and other Vietnamese books keep the traditional stock of configurations intact for reference.
Đại hạn and Tuần Triệt: where do the two schools use them differently?
The starting point of đại hạn and the use of Tuần and Triệt are two clear points of divergence between the books, and the Vietnamese books themselves do not agree with one another.
On đại hạn, Vietnamese books usually start the cycles from the cục number and the yin-yang sex, but the direction of counting and the starting marker differ from book to book. Thiên Lương in Tử Vi nghiệm lý toàn thư repeatedly relies on age and palace to calculate cycle markers; for a Nhâm Tuất person, for example, he holds that at age 45 Triệt breaks Đà La in the Mệnh palace and releases Tuần in the Thân palace. That way of speaking shows Tuần and Triệt being used as two factors that can "open" or "lock" a palace over time, not merely as fixed malefic stars.
On Tuần Triệt, Tử Vi đẩu số tân biên uses them as factors of rescue or of breaking a configuration depending on position. The book writes: for a person with Tham Lang in hãm địa meeting Đào Hoa, the reading is usually of a cruel and deeply scheming person, "nhưng trong trường hợp này, nếu Tham, Đào gặp Tuần, Triệt án ngữ, lại là người nhân hậu và đoan chính" (but in this case, if Tham and Đào meet Tuần and Triệt pressing on them, the person is instead kind and upright). Thiên Lương goes further, holding that Tuần Triệt can entirely change a star's nature according to age and palace, and he uses real people's charts to illustrate.
What is Việt Viêm Tử's own method in Tử Vi áo bí biện chứng học?
Việt Viêm Tử has conventions of his own, among them the method of "Mệnh ngồi hai cung tính một cục" (the Mệnh palace sitting across two palaces counts as one cục), and this is one author's own method, not the common standard of all Vietnamese books.
Việt Viêm Tử's Tử Vi áo bí biện chứng học presents the cục by combining heavenly stems, earthly branches and the eight trigrams, dividing the twelve earthly-branch palaces into four tam hợp cục, then splitting them into four yang cục and four yin cục. This reasoning differs from the simple calculation of the cục from the year stem and Mệnh palace found in many popular books. The book also gives transformation tables by stem, in which the stem Canh takes Thiên Đồng hóa Khoa and Thái Âm hóa Kỵ, differing from some other transformation tables in circulation.
It should be stated clearly: this is one author's convention, not a common rule that everyone studying Tử Vi in Vietnam follows. A reader who wants to compare must consult that specific book, not infer it for other Vietnamese books.
How does Thiên Lương study Tử Vi through real people's charts?
Thiên Lương in Tử Vi nghiệm lý toàn thư takes the charts of people whose lives are already known as material for verification, and from there draws out rules.
The book cites the chart of Á Nam Trần Tuấn Khải, born in the year Ất Mùi, on the 18th day of the ninth lunar month at the hour of Sửu, then analyses the Mệnh and Thân palaces and the stars gathered there to explain why a man whose writing moved the hearts of the people had such a chart. He also compares the case of Sào Nam tiên sinh, observing that both men share the circumstance "Mệnh Tang Môn thân Quan Phù đắc Riêu Xương Khoa Quyền Lộc" (Mệnh with Tang Môn, Thân with Quan Phù, obtaining Riêu, Xương, Khoa, Quyền, Lộc). This method differs from learning from verses: instead of starting from a verse line and then finding a chart to illustrate it, he starts from a known life and then sees what the chart says.
The limitation of this method is that the sample is small and the choice of people for verification may be influenced by what is already known, so the results are not to be taken as scientific evidence. presents this as the experience of one researcher, not as a verified law.
Is the lục bát Phú Tử Vi attributed to Lê Quý Đôn trustworthy?
The lục bát Phú Tử Vi is traditionally attributed to Lê Quý Đôn, but this is a tradition of attribution, and no text proves it.
Twentieth-century Vietnamese books repeatedly cite the lục bát Phú Tử Vi as an ancient source, and some popular material assigns the authorship to Lê Quý Đôn. However, such attribution rests on word of mouth and on the habit of citing sources; no contemporary manuscript or publication confirms it. Modern research does not regard this as proven. So when using the phú for reference, one should know that it is a traditional text, not an established work of Lê Quý Đôn.
Comparison table of rules between the Vietnamese book style and the Trung Châu school
| Rule or method | Vietnamese book style | Trung Châu school | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Number of auxiliary stars | Uses many auxiliary stars, with its own star groups | Uses its own star system, with adjustments | Tân Biên, sơ cấp giảng nghĩa |
| Grading of stars | Grades miếu, vượng, đắc, hãm | Does not grade stars | Sơ cấp giảng nghĩa |
| Method of learning combinations | Verse judgement for each configuration | Twelve boards, sixty star systems | Thâm tạo giảng nghĩa |
| Tả Hữu đồng cung configuration | Recorded as a good configuration | Called a false configuration | Vương Đình Chi đàm đẩu số |
| Thiên Ất củng mệnh configuration | Recorded as a good configuration | Called a false configuration | Vương Đình Chi đàm đẩu số |
| Starting point of đại hạn | By cục and sex, with differences between books | ||
| Use of Tuần Triệt | Tân Biên: rescue or breaking a configuration depending on position; Thiên Lương: opening or locking a palace by age | Tân Biên, Tử Vi nghiệm lý | |
| Own conventions on the cục | Việt Viêm Tử has his own method of calculation | Tử Vi áo bí biện chứng học |
The star-placement table of the Nhat Nguyet tool follows the popular Vietnamese style, not any single school.
