
TL;DR: Paired stars such as Tả Phù, Hữu Bật, Văn Xương, Văn Khúc, Thiên Khôi, Thiên Việt, Kình Dương, Đà La, Địa Không and Địa Kiếp are placed by the same marker (birth month, birth hour or year stem), so their positions always have a fixed relation: đồng cung, xung chiếu, hội tam hợp or giáp (flanking a palace on both sides). Old books and schools do not agree on the weight order of these four positions; Vương Đình Chi holds that đồng cung is strongest, xung chiếu weaker, hội hợp weaker still, and giáp weakest, and criticises calling the giáp position 'ám củng' as forced. The article presents the differing views and the points not yet verified, without asserting absolute auspiciousness or inauspiciousness.
# Paired stars in Tử Vi (Tả Hữu, Xương Khúc, Khôi Việt, Kình Đà, Không Kiếp): when they share a palace, face each other, meet in the tam hợp, or flank a palace, how do the books read them differently?
Why do these stars always travel in pairs?
In Tử Vi (Vietnamese astrology), some stars never appear alone in terms of position, because they are placed from the same reference point: birth month, birth hour, or the heavenly stem of the birth year. Because they share that reference point, the positions of the two stars in a pair always stand in a fixed geometric relationship on the chart. That is why people speak of "paired stars" and discuss four configurations: đồng cung (the two stars in the same palace), xung chiếu (the two stars in two opposite palaces), hội tam hợp (the two stars within the same three-palace tam hợp set), and giáp (the two stars in the two palaces flanking some palace on either side).
For example, Tả Phù and Hữu Bật are placed by birth month. Under the placement method in Việt Viêm Tử's Tử Vi áo bí biện chứng học, in the 4th lunar month Tả Phù and Hữu Bật share the palace at Mùi; in the 10th month they share the palace at Sửu. Also according to Việt Viêm Tử, Địa Kiếp and Địa Không are placed by birth hour: in the Tý hour they share the palace at Hợi, in the Ngọ hour they share the palace at Tỵ. These are positions that can be calculated from the star placement rules, not guesswork.
The shared-palace positions of Tả Hữu in the 4th and 10th months and of Không Kiếp in the Tý and Ngọ hours are the result of the star placement procedure and can be cross-checked against the placement tables in the books. Whether those positions are good or bad is a matter of each school's interpretive rules, not of calculation.
What is the order of strength among đồng cung, xung chiếu, hội hợp and giáp?
Vương Đình Chi, in the Trung Châu phái Tử Vi đẩu số, discussing Văn Xương and Văn Khúc, writes that these two stars "dĩ đồng cung đích lực lượng tối đại; tương đối thì thứ chi; hội hợp thì hựu thứ chi; tương giáp tắc lực lượng giác nhược". That is: sharing a palace is strongest, opposition is weaker, meeting in the tam hợp is weaker still, and flanking is the weakest. He also criticises calling the giáp configuration "ám củng" (hidden support) as forced, since giáp merely means two stars on either side, not shining into the same palace in the sense of tam hợp or xung chiếu.
This ordering is the view of one school, not a common rule that all books agree on. Other books may rank them differently or may not distinguish them so clearly.
Is Tả Hữu sharing a palace a good configuration?
Old books contain the saying "Tả Phù Hữu Bật, chung thân phúc hậu", meaning that whoever has Tả Hữu shining in conjunction enjoys deep good fortune all their life. From this arose the "Tả Hữu đồng cung" configuration (also called "Tả Hữu đồng viên"), which holds that these two stars in the same palace make a good configuration. But Vương Đình Chi calls it a "ngụy cách" (false configuration), because Tả Hữu are only assistant stars and cannot by themselves form a good configuration without a major star[1]. His argument: if being born in the 4th or 10th month meant Tả Hữu share a palace, would everyone born in those two months become a high official? That is absurd[1].
He also holds that Tả Hữu are strongest when they flank a well-placed major star on both sides (such as Tử Vi or Thái Dương), not when they share a palace with each other[1]. This is where the books disagree: some old books still praise the Tả Hữu đồng cung configuration, while Vương Đình Chi rejects it.
Khôi Việt: what does the Trung Châu phái say about their positions?
Thiên Khôi and Thiên Việt are placed by the heavenly stem of the birth year. Vương Đình Chi notes that these two stars can stand in three configurations: xung chiếu (as at Sửu and Mùi), hội hợp (as at Tý and Thân), or giáp (as at Hợi and Dậu)[2]. He also says Khôi Việt need not be in the Mệnh palace to be good; in other palaces such as Điền Trạch, Phụ Mẫu and Phúc Đức they also have an effect, but he cautions against leaving Khôi Việt alone in the palaces of the six relations, since this may bring two sets of parents, two sets of siblings, or two marriages[4].
This view differs from the common understanding that Khôi Việt must be in the Mệnh palace, or flank it, to be precious. Other books may focus only on Mệnh and Thân.
Do Kình Đà always flank Lộc Tồn?
Kình Dương and Đà La are placed by the heavenly stem of the birth year, and under the placement rules they always flank Lộc Tồn in the middle. This is a fixed positional relationship. Vương Đình Chi discusses pairs of malefic stars flanking a palace, such as "Hỏa Linh giáp mệnh vi bại cục" (Hỏa Tinh and Linh Tinh flanking Mệnh is a ruinous configuration), "Dương Đà giáp" (Kình Dương and Đà La flanking), and "Không Kiếp giáp" (Địa Không and Địa Kiếp flanking)[3]. He holds that these flanking configurations are usually weaker than đồng cung or xung chiếu, but still have a certain effect, depending on the major star and the other stars.
Note: this is one school's interpretation, not yet verified statistically. Other books may weigh them differently.
Where the books differ, and where no one has verified anything
There are at least three points on which the books disagree:
- The order of strength of the four configurations. Vương Đình Chi ranks đồng cung > xung chiếu > hội hợp > giáp, but some old books may regard the tam hợp as stronger than xung chiếu, or regard giáp as having a special effect in some cases.
- The Tả Hữu đồng cung configuration. Old books praise it; Vương Đình Chi rejects it[1].
- The positions of Khôi Việt. The Trung Châu phái holds that Khôi Việt can be good in many palaces[4], while many books stress only Mệnh and Thân.
No study has verified these interpretations by statistical or experimental methods. All of them are rules of the various schools, based on oral tradition and old texts, not on the results of experimental science.
Table comparing the star pairs and their positional configurations
| Star pair | Placed by | Months/hours of đồng cung | Months/hours of xung chiếu |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tả Phù, Hữu Bật | Birth month | Month 4: Mùi; month 10: Sửu | Month 1: Thìn and Tuất (Tả at Thìn, Hữu at Tuất); month 7: the reverse |
| Văn Xương, Văn Khúc | Birth hour | Mão hour: Mùi; Dậu hour: Sửu | Tý hour: Thìn and Tuất; Ngọ hour: the reverse |
| Thiên Khôi, Thiên Việt | Year stem | (No stem gives đồng cung) | Giáp and Mậu stems: Sửu and Mùi[2] |
| Kình Dương, Đà La | Year stem | (Always flank Lộc Tồn, never share a palace with each other) | (Never in xung chiếu) |
| Địa Không, Địa Kiếp | Birth hour | Tý hour: Hợi; Ngọ hour: Tỵ | Mão hour: Dần and Thân; Dậu hour: Thân and Dần |
This table lists only the typical cases cited in the books; other months and hours can be derived from the star placement rules.
Reference tables for the positions of the paired stars
The three tables below are taken from the exact star placement method of the /tien-ich/tu-vi tool. The relationship column states only how the two stars of a pair stand relative to each other on the chart; whether that pair meets the Mệnh palace still depends on where the Mệnh palace lies.
| Lunar birth month | Tả Phù | Hữu Bật | Relationship |
|---|---|---|---|
| Month 1 | Thìn | Tuất | xung chiếu |
| Month 2 | Tỵ | Dậu | tam hợp |
| Month 3 | Ngọ | Thân | flanking one palace in between (giáp) |
| Month 4 | Mùi | Mùi | đồng cung |
| Month 5 | Thân | Ngọ | flanking one palace in between (giáp) |
| Month 6 | Dậu | Tỵ | tam hợp |
| Month 7 | Tuất | Thìn | xung chiếu |
| Month 8 | Hợi | Mão | tam hợp |
| Month 9 | Tý | Dần | flanking one palace in between (giáp) |
| Month 10 | Sửu | Sửu | đồng cung |
| Month 11 | Dần | Tý | flanking one palace in between (giáp) |
| Month 12 | Mão | Hợi | tam hợp |
| Birth hour | Văn Xương | Văn Khúc | Xương Khúc relationship | Địa Không | Địa Kiếp | Không Kiếp relationship |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tý hour | Tuất | Thìn | xung chiếu | Hợi | Hợi | đồng cung |
| Sửu hour | Dậu | Tỵ | tam hợp | Tuất | Tý | flanking one palace in between (giáp) |
| Dần hour | Thân | Ngọ | flanking one palace in between (giáp) | Dậu | Sửu | tam hợp |
| Mão hour | Mùi | Mùi | đồng cung | Thân | Dần | xung chiếu |
| Thìn hour | Ngọ | Thân | flanking one palace in between (giáp) | Mùi | Mão | tam hợp |
| Tỵ hour | Tỵ | Dậu | tam hợp | Ngọ | Thìn | flanking one palace in between (giáp) |
| Ngọ hour | Thìn | Tuất | xung chiếu | Tỵ | Tỵ | đồng cung |
| Mùi hour | Mão | Hợi | tam hợp | Thìn | Ngọ | flanking one palace in between (giáp) |
| Thân hour | Dần | Tý | flanking one palace in between (giáp) | Mão | Mùi | tam hợp |
| Dậu hour | Sửu | Sửu | đồng cung | Dần | Thân | xung chiếu |
| Tuất hour | Tý | Dần | flanking one palace in between (giáp) | Sửu | Dậu | tam hợp |
| Hợi hour | Hợi | Mão | tam hợp | Tý | Tuất | flanking one palace in between (giáp) |
| Birth year stem | Thiên Khôi | Thiên Việt | Lộc Tồn | Kình Dương | Đà La |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Giáp | Sửu | Mùi | Dần | Mão | Sửu |
| Ất | Tý | Thân | Mão | Thìn | Dần |
| Bính | Hợi | Dậu | Tỵ | Ngọ | Thìn |
| Đinh | Hợi | Dậu | Ngọ | Mùi | Tỵ |
| Mậu | Sửu | Mùi | Tỵ | Ngọ | Thìn |
| Kỷ | Tý | Thân | Ngọ | Mùi | Tỵ |
| Canh | Ngọ | Dần | Thân | Dậu | Mùi |
| Tân | Ngọ | Dần | Dậu | Tuất | Thân |
| Nhâm | Mão | Tỵ | Hợi | Tý | Tuất |
| Quý | Mão | Tỵ | Tý | Sửu | Hợi |
